Monday, April 13, 2009

Who was at Godrics Hollow the night James and Lily were killed?

J.K. Rowling said at one point that the makers of Philosopher%26#039;s Stone the movie were good at predicting stuff because they put the shadow of another person in the scene that shows Lily%26#039;s death. I read the Deathly Hollows and I can%26#039;t find who she%26#039;s talking about. From what I read the only ones there were James, Lily, Harry and Voldemort. Did she write the scene differently than she was planning to at that time or did I get the quote wrong or is there someone there that I missed?

Who was at Godrics Hollow the night James and Lily were killed?
I don%26#039;t remember anyone being there other than James, Lily, Harry, and Voldemort. It goes back and describes it in detail. Of course, it could have been Wormtail she was talking about and, especially if she said this a while back, she could have changed that part of it.
Reply:There can%26#039;t have been anyone else there or else Harry wouldn%26#039;t have been a Horcrux.
Reply:If anything I would think finding out in book 3 that Peter was the one that gave there location away that he may of been there. in the form of a rat perhaps? Aside from that, yep noone else was there from what I read.
Reply:I read the scene the same as you with only the three Potters and Voldemort there.
Reply:Hmm....idk. i don%26#039;t think anyone else was there.
Reply:well, maybe at the time he killed it was just the three because it does say Harry was the only living thing in the room for the horcrux, but she does say that Snape pleaded with Voldemort not to kill Lily, maybe he went there and tried but then was asked to leave???
Reply:She may have said that way back when and then never made anything more out of it. More than likley it was just the Potter%26#039;s and Voldie.



acne scar

No comments:

Post a Comment